Jump to content

Richard Dawkins Event Canceled Over Past Comments About Islam


Recommended Posts



A public radio station in Berkeley, Calif., said it canceled a live discussion and book signing with the evolutionary biologist and noted atheist Richard Dawkins because of his past comments criticizing Islam.

Mr. Dawkins was to promote his new book, “Science in the Soul: Selected Writings of a Passionate Rationalist,” before an audience of hundreds of paying ticket holders on Aug. 9. The event was also to be a fund-raiser for its host, the radio station KPFA.

The station sent an email to ticketholders on Thursday that praised the book but apologized for not having “broader knowledge” of his views much earlier. It added that Mr. Dawkins had hurt people with “his tweets and other comments on Islam.”

The email was quoted in full by Mr. Dawkins in an open letterthat criticized the station’s decision on Friday.

He said in a phone interview on Saturday that he learned about the cancellation only after a ticketholder received the email and forwarded it to him. He said he had received no further explanation from the station.

“Many people are saying this is a freedom of speech issue, and of course it is,” he said. “But it’s actually more of a freedom of listening issue. People bought tickets because they wanted to hear me.”

In recent months, the cancellation of speeches on college campuses has stirred debates over balancing free speech andsecurity concerns.

Berkeley has been a particular focus. In February, the University of California, Berkeley, canceled a speech by Milo Yiannopoulos, a right-wing writer and commentator, after a violent demonstration. In April, the university canceled a speech by the conservative author Ann Coulter, citing security concerns. KPFA, however, is not affiliated with the university.

Bob Baldock, the events coordinator for the station, said in a phone interview on Saturday that he could not recall in his three decades at the station any other live event it hosted being canceled because of its content.

The decision was made by the station’s management, and Mr. Baldock said he lent his support, but he called the cancellation a “fraught decision.”

“I could probably do my best at defending Dawkins,” he said. “I’m very fond of him. I’ve liked his books.”

He added that Mr. Dawkins’s unscripted remarks and social media posts gave him pause. “He has said things that I know have hurt people,” Mr. Baldock said.

Some of the first objections to Mr. Dawkins’s appearance came from Bay Area residents. They pointed to his tweets like one posted in 2013 in which he called Islam “the greatest force for evil in the world today.”

Henry Norr, a former KPFA board member, criticized Mr. Dawkins in a July 17 email to the station. “Yes, he’s a rationalist, an atheist and an advocate of the science of evolution — great, so am I,” Mr. Norr wrote. “But he’s also an outspoken Islamophobe — have you done your homework about that?”

Lara Kiswani, the executive director of the Arab Resource andOrganizing Center, which is based in San Francisco, also emailed the station last week. She said Mr. Dawkins’s comments give legitimacy to extremist views.

“KPFA is a progressive institution in the Bay Area, and an institution that reflects social justice,” she said in a phone interview on Saturday. “It isn’t required to give such anti-Islam rhetoric a platform.”

Quincy McCoy, the station’s general manager, did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. In a KPFA news broadcast on Friday, he said the station “emphatically supports free speech.”

He added, “We believe that it is our free speech right not to participate with anyone who uses hateful or hurtful language against a community that is already under attack.”

Several of Mr. Dawkins’s comments on social media have drawn criticism in recent years. In 2015, he wondered whether Ahmed Mohamed — the boy in Texas who was suspended after bringing a homemade clock to school that officials said resembled a bomb —wanted to get arrested given that the episode led to an invitation to the White House and crowdfunding. In a Twitter post in 2014, he suggested that people should “always put Islamic ‘scholar’ in quotes, to avoid insulting true scholars.”

“True scholars have read more than one book,” he wrote.

Mr. Dawkins stood by those tweets on Saturday. “I’ve been criticizing all religions for years,” including Christianity, he said. He added that he lived in Berkeley during the late 1960s and was once a frequent listener and supporter of KPFA.

Mr. Dawkins said he objected to the idea that speakers who might be offensive should be turned away from institutions of higher learning.

“I do think that the business of universities is to expose students to all kinds of views,” he said. “If somebody objectionable like Ann Coulter comes on, they should argue with her.”

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dawkins has been making similarly snide remarks about Christianity for years and I don't recall any of his engagements being cancelled over it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It seems Political Correctness is reaching it's peak (I hope).  It appears Mr. Dawkins is an equal opportunity atheist, but in the Berkeley world:

On 7/24/2017 at 6:24 PM, Auburn85 said:

“We believe that it is our free speech right not to participate with anyone who uses hateful or hurtful language against a community that is already under attack.”

I guess no one can disagree with anything that may offend.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dawkins is anti-religion.  If at any point he encounters a religion that he believes clashes in some way with his scientism and his armchair metaphysics, he makes acidic and disparaging remarks about it.  He often steps outside his realm of expertise in doing so and looks silly, but no one can say he's not equal opportunity in his criticisms.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Create New...