I see being 1A from a different perspective.
When I first started coaching baseball. I had just moved and was in a VERY small town where I knew nobody and no one knew me. This was the equivalent of a 1A league.
My son was 5. We joined a 5 and under league. Kids were assigned teams. I said "I don't care, just give me a team."
Turns out, the locals (as normal) knew the good players and families. But they stacked one team with the best players at the expense of mine. I got only scraps. I only had 9 players. other teams had 14 . The big team had 18... They were undefeated and had never been behind in a game even for one inning. 1 of my kids was only 4 years old. One was 3 and only sat in the field and cried. ( we are talking Bad News Bears 1 type team here)
BUT!!!! One of the kids had crack addicted parents. (the reason he was put on my team). Only saw his parents one time. This kid lived with his grandparents. (granddad was obviously a baseball aficionado) This kid was the most talented baseball player I have ever seen. He had perfect fundamentals and form. Always hit the ball and got on base. Could hit, catch and throw amazingly well compared to kids 3-4 years older than he was. He understood the game of baseball at 4 years old. He was my star player, and better than anyone else in the league BY FAR! Just naturally a baseball player. HE had gift from God! Esp when he was being serious.
I have heard that coaches can coach for decades and only have 1 player with the telnet that MAY go pro. I had mine on my first team! He was a prodigy.
This kid would have ben a 5* where ever he played. Tiny town or big city.
He was also hilarious and entertaining to watch! He was so good it was like watching the king and his court. He was actually bored with the game. He would literally MOCK the game of baseball when he knew he was doing well. i.e. When he would hit the ball hard enough and far enough he would run in slow motion, squat down and "duck walk" the bases. Often, Kids on third base , and even second base, would score before this kid would duck walk out of the batters box. (vid link below. BTW the kid refused to use a properly weighted bat in this game he wanted to use his cousins 31 oz -ish bat other videos show his form and fundamentals but this shows how entertaining he was to watch. )
Turns out in the championship game we were beating the stacked team for the first 3 innings. The stack team came back and won in the 4th, but we had their ball sacks shriveled up for over an hour! LOL
THE SAD: the kids crack parents took back custody of the kid and he never played ball again.
TLDR: Talent can come from anywhere.
^^ Ironically, the two nerdiest players in the league were both named Richard and they meet in the vid above.
IF you made it this far, I have dozens of stories about this kid and that specific team.