D.J. Hall and The Incredible Shrinking Suspension

[DKW 86 7,438]

Sunday, November 18, 2007

D.J. Hall and The Incredible Shrinking Suspension

Alabama fans were greeted Saturday with the game-time announcement that the team's star player, receiver D.J. Hall, would be suspended for what was expected to be a "tune-up game" against lightly-regarded Louisiana-Monroe. AL.com bloggers Paul Gattis (Huntsville Times) and Ian Rapoport (Birmingham News) both reported before kickoff that Hall's suspension would be for the ULM game; there was no mention in the contemporaneous accounts of a "one half suspension."

Flash forward a couple of hours. As Alabama was tied with ULM in the second half and being dominated throughout the third quarter, Hall's suspension was magically lifted and he returned to play (as it happened, it didn't matter whether Hall was on the field or not; UAT was shut out in the second half). Gattis, to his credit, reiterated the point about Hall's suspension at that time:

Alabama leading receiver DJ Hall, who was said to have been suspended for today's game, started the second half for the Tide.

Hall did not play in the first half.

UA football SID Jeff Purinton said that Hall would not play today because of a violation of team policy.

After the game, Rapoport asked Alabama Coach Nick "I am not going to be the Alabama coach" Saban about Hall's sudden reinstatement, and received the following enlightening response:

I asked Saban post-game if receiver DJ Hall was suspended for 30 minutes from the beginning. As in, was it a game suspension that turned into a half suspension?

"It was what it was," he said.

So, I asked, a half suspension?

"What it was," Saban said.

C'mon, Flipper. Everybody knows you're a snake and a liar who'll do anything to win football games. Why not go ahead and admit it: not losing to a bottom-feeder was a lot more important to you than maintaining discipline in your program. You panicked and put Hall back in the game because you didn't think you could win without him (you were wrong, of course, but that's beside the point).

You know, this team looks more and more like it's still being coached by Mike Shula. Discipline problems, charges of favoritism from the coaches, long losing streaks and now a loss to one of the worst teams in the country. Has anything really changed other than the coach being a jackass and the school paying a whole lot more money for the same results? Why not just give Hall an ice cream cone and make it official?

posted by Will Collier at 11/18/2007

Can anyone else hear that quote coming back to haunt Nick the Prick: "It was what it was."

"It all depends on what your definition of the word 'is' is..." Bill Clinton

[aubiescottie 1]

Saw a fabulous post on the al.com blogs today; said that if what Hall did deserved a full game suspension [as Saban stated], but out of 'compassion' for Hall's family, he let him play the second half. Shouldn't Hall be suspended for the first half of the Auburn game? I believe will win Saturday either way, but its a great point to think about.

http://blog.al.com/rapsheet/2007/11/explan...lls_suspen.html

[DKW 86 7,438]

Saw a fabulous post on the al.com blogs today; said that if what Hall did deserved a full game suspension [as Saban stated], but out of 'compassion' for Hall's family, he let him play the second half. Shouldn't Hall be suspended for the first half of the Auburn game? I believe will win Saturday either way, but its a great point to think about.

http://blog.al.com/rapsheet/2007/11/explan...lls_suspen.html

You so funny...

[AU alum 2]

Saw a fabulous post on the al.com blogs today; said that if what Hall did deserved a full game suspension [as Saban stated], but out of 'compassion' for Hall's family, he let him play the second half. Shouldn't Hall be suspended for the first half of the Auburn game? I believe will win Saturday either way, but its a great point to think about.

http://blog.al.com/rapsheet/2007/11/explan...lls_suspen.html

I think suspending DJ for the first half of the Auburn game is their ONLY chance of making this go away. I really don't think it will go away, even if that happens, but the uproar might be quieted somewhat. But, it isn't going to happen, so this is just a rhetorical exercise.

[townhallsavoy 2]

I think suspending DJ for the first half of the Auburn game is their ONLY chance of making this go away. I really don't think it will go away, even if that happens, but the uproar might be quieted somewhat. But, it isn't going to happen, so this is just a rhetorical exercise.

The uproar would switch sides. Can you imagine how loud the Bama faithful would scream if Saban suspended their best player for one second of the Iron Bowl? Especially after letting him play against ULM?

[abrnfanatc 6]

Saw a fabulous post on the al.com blogs today; said that if what Hall did deserved a full game suspension [as Saban stated], but out of 'compassion' for Hall's family, he let him play the second half. Shouldn't Hall be suspended for the first half of the Auburn game? I believe will win Saturday either way, but its a great point to think about.

http://blog.al.com/rapsheet/2007/11/explan...lls_suspen.html

I think suspending DJ for the first half of the Auburn game is their ONLY chance of making this go away. I really don't think it will go away, even if that happens, but the uproar might be quieted somewhat. But, it isn't going to happen, so this is just a rhetorical exercise.

I will eat BG's houndstooth hat if anyone on the Bammer team was suspended for even one play against Auburn. The only way to teach these kids to do this the right way is to let them play...